The outgoing U of G President believes off-campus student housing is beneficial to the community

Posted May 25, 2014

In a wide-ranging interview with the Guelph Mercury, U of G President Alastair Summerlee, said, “one of the really neat things about the Guelph community is that we’ve had students sort of spread out and that I think is good for each of the different pockets of the city.”

And he added: “ Getting away from that model and gathering students much more densely may create ‘be careful what you wish for’ scenario for Guelph where noise, ‘instant partying’ and related troubles become much more live issues.”

Really! I guess in his 11-year term of office, that saw the student population grow almost 90 per cent, the president did not get out much in the community.

He reveals why the city and university share a collegial relationship. During an Ontario Municipal Board (OMB) hearing, this “relationship” opposed an off-campus large student housing project at the corner of Gordon Street and Stone Road. It was just across the street from the university campus.

The OMB approved the project, rejecting the argument that the behaviour of the resident students could not be controlled by the university, and would cause problems to residents in the area.

Yet, Mr. Summerlee brags about how off-campus student housing in many single family zoned neighbourhoods described it as a “really neat thing about the Guelph community.”

So this is how the collegial arrangement works between the city and university. The city administration allows these quasi mini-apartments to be created. Then fails to enforce its own bylaws that guarantee peace and goodwill among neighbors. It is prevalent in wards five and six areas that are occupied by residents who never dreamed that their new student neighbours would behave badly failing to meet the established standards of the neighbourhood.

There has been a lack of bylaw enforcement; police protection and owners of many of these student lodgings don’t even live in Guelph. There is little or no supervision by landlords. Many neighbourhoods are terrorized by loud parties, music and the sale of alcoholic beverages by student entrepreneurs.

Hardly any of this is reported in the press.

It is difficult to believe that the university president was not aware of the breakdown of relations between his students and residents in areas throughout wards five and six.

It appears, through his own words, that he is indirectly opposed to the proposed rental-licensing bylaw that is before council. It is designed to force landlords to control the homes they have converted to student use. Also to allow bylaw officers more access to check the student homes for safety and building standards.

It’s also no surprise that the landlords, collectively, have waged a strong campaign opposing the proposed licensing bylaw. So much so that passage may not occur during this council’s mandate. The can could be kicked down the road.

In his interview the president commented on how in 11 years on the job, he feels he has been successful in bringing city council and the university administration together and achieving common goals.

Last year the university announced it has a $34 million operating deficit. This resulted in layoffs and program cutbacks. Then it was revealed that the university pension plan was seriously underfunded and was not included in the balance sheet as a liability.

Starting to see some similarities here? The city has spent its way into a similar position where revenues are not matching expenditures. In the case of the city, it must juggle the books to report a balanced result annually to the Province.

This is why your property tax bills have increased by 35 per cent in eight years. This is why your water bills have increased by 77 per cent. This is why user fees have doubled in some cases. This is why the Mayor is musing about new special tax levies to carry out her dream of creating a new Guelph.

Perhaps citizens should think carefully about electing those councillors who have blindly supported the ambitious expansion of the university.

The imminent departure of President Summerlee should coincide with Mayor Farbridge and her seven cohorts being defeated next October 27.

But then the president doesn’t have to run for office and citizens have a choice to change the way the city is being run.






Filed under Between the Lines

5 responses to “The outgoing U of G President believes off-campus student housing is beneficial to the community

  1. fairpensions09

    Sweet on his way out with a $300,000 a year pension what is he almost 55?

    Won’t be too long before he gets a real job, a juicy government posting of course

    Sent on the TELUS Mobility network with BlackBerry

  2. joe Black

    Please enlighten me when was the last time the U of G had a property assessment ??????

    • Joe Black: Not in my memory. The university property tax is based on the number of students. It is called the bed tax and is $75. The rate has not changed since 1987. Wouldn’t taxpayers like to have a deal like that? In the past eight Farbridge years, property taxes in the city have increased by 35 per cent. The only added cost to the university is the increase in the number of students in 27 years. The result is the property taxpayers of Guelph are subsidizing the university and have been for 27 years. Don’t expect the Farbridge council to attempt any change, they’re too cozy with the university administration.

  3. Fred

    Rotting garbage, weeds and drunks yelling in front of your house at 3 AM.
    Paying bus drivers overtime to drive empty buses 4 months of the year.
    Taxpayers are actually starting to hate the slumlords, the university
    propaganda, city hall waste and the churlish delinquents.

  4. Mary Heyens

    I have a “Really Neat Idea” Alastair, refund the Guelph Taxpayers before you leave town. Why am I standing in line at the Food Bank next to young and old capable people who cannot find work?
    2012: university’s president, Alastair Summerlee, earned $490,857.66 – $465,723.79 in salary and $25,133.87 in taxable benefits. He has held the position since 2003.
    2013: Summerlee earned $465,692.03 – $440,589.92 in salary and $25,102.11 in taxable benefits.
    It looks like President Summerlee and Mayor Farbridge wear the same “friends forever” necklace.
    RE: Sunshine List March 29, 2014 Guelph Mercury: Gregory Thomas, federal director of the Canadian Taxpayers Federation, says with so many families struggling to make ends meet, it’s a “disconcerting” to see police officers, fire fighters and teachers earning so much money.
    “People working outside of government in Real Ontario are scrambling for every dime,” said Thomas in a phone interview. “But government workers seem to have the golden ticket. It’s disconcerting to see the biggest addition to the six-figure income list among this group. They have six-figure incomes, but not six-figure jobs.”
    STOP FARBRIDGE and HER COUNCIL- Make your October vote count and protect our families’ future.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s