Who was minding the store when this city-financed indoor soccer deal was hatched?

Posted September 12, 2013

It seemed like a good idea at the time.

Build an indoor soccer pitch in Centennial Park and they will come.

Five years ago, Mayor Farbridge opened the facility that was to be operated by Guelph Community Sports with the Guelph Soccer Club as tenants.

Nobody considered that soccer is a warm weather sport that is played outside for seven months of the year in Canada. During that time the soccer dome sits idle with little revenue. The argument provided was that the dome, built in Centennial Park, is not air-conditioned.

In July, Guelph Community Sports told the city it could no longer make the payments on the $900,000 mortgage that has $500,000 still outstanding. In fact, the August payment was not made and the mortgage is now in arrears.

It is not clear who owns this structure. It is built on city land but who is the registered owner?

The taxpayers of Guelph are now on the hook for that amount because the city guaranteed the loan. Guelph Community Sports is also a guarantor but they apparently have no money. Guelph Soccer refuses to guarantee the mortgage although it would use the facility for the next ten years if a deal could be salvaged.

City staff has been negotiating a solution that includes extending the mortgage amortization period to 15 years to reduce the mortgage payment by 50 per cent.

This is where it gets sticky. The playing surface has to be replaced in 2018 and the Dome itself must be replaced in 2023. Both those fixes are expensive and must be completed before the mortgage is paid off.

This project was star-crossed from the beginning. It is apparent there was no business plan that nailed down the obligation of Guelph Community Sports. Such questions as the ability to pay down the mortgage and maintain the building for the original amortization period, come to mind.

Was there any monitoring of the operations, in the past five years, on the part of the city staff? Was there any reserve for repairs and replacement in the original budget?

Was it ever considered that playing soccer all year round is a very expensive proposition, particularly in a country like Canada?

Does the city not provide playing fields for soccer enthusiasts to enjoy during the warmer months?

What was the thinking behind guaranteeing taxpayer support to allow soccer to be played year around?

Even city hockey facilities close down during the summer months.

It is another example of special interest groups receiving taxpayer support for their projects without a careful analysis of the financial consequences.

This is a similar situation to what occurred during Mayor Fabridge’s first term, when the now known as the Sleeman Centre, was turned over to a Calgary company to operate the facility. That deal also fell apart when the operator failed to pay the mortgage on the building and meet other obligations. It eventually cost the taxpayers $4 million to return the operation to city control.

Somebody must watch the store if this soccer deal is to be rescued.


Filed under Between the Lines

9 responses to “Who was minding the store when this city-financed indoor soccer deal was hatched?

  1. The name Nustadia comes to mind and I still shudder. Mr. Bigelli.
    The term special interest groups seems to be getting thrown about lately.
    Why not simply follow protocol when making decisions that will have an impact on my tax dollar ..something like MAJORITY RULES

  2. paul

    F ool hearty
    A ssinine
    R arely thinks further than her nose
    B ungles most deals in Guelph
    R id of her
    I diotic dictator
    D oesn’t have a clue how to run a city
    E ntered senility zone years ago

  3. paul

    oops!!! left the G out….G is for Glad when she is gone!!!!!

  4. A Different Paul

    Good stuff Paul
    I second the G thought!

    A different Paul but one who shares the sentiment!

  5. JC

    $50,000 to provide hydro and water infrustructure for the Guelph Juntion Express doesn’t seem like such a bad deal now. Especially when the infrustructure would have have never gone to waste even if the operation ceased at some point (unlike this project). I guess it’s ok to pee away tax dollars in the name of not-for-profit.

    • JC: That was a dumb mistake by council and possibly politically motivated to turn down support for the Junction Express. But it pales in comparison to the more than $50 million the Farbridge administration laid out. It included the $36 million organics processing plant with its capacity three times the needs of the city for the next 20 years. Then spend $15 million for a collection system that fails to serve 6,400 households because the city refuses to pick up its garbage. These projects are an insult to the community and a betrayal of the public trust. In 2008, the Farbridge-dominated council approved the 25-year solid waste management plan. It will be remembered as a day of infamy.

  6. geo

    Why was an indoor soccer facility built without air conditioning?

    • paul

      Just another of many goof ups by the City of Guelph wise guys at City Hall! Bet the mayor’s new office has air conditioning….they didn’t forget to install that and sure made room in the budget for it….

  7. Jeff

    Where is my ScrabbleDome? <<>>

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s